Congruity in Korean-American Adolescents' and Their Parents' Perceptions of Parent-Child Relationships

Sunday, November 1, 2009

Heeseung Choi, PhD, MPH, RN1
Barbara Dancy, RN, PhD, FAAN1
Louis Fogg, PhD2
Eunice Lee, PhD, RN1
1College of Nursing, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL
2Community and Mental Health Nursing, Rush University College of Nursing, Chicago, IL

Learning Objective 1: discuss the congruity between Korean American adolescents and their parents report on parental knowledge, parental/filial self-efficacy, parent-child communication, and parent-child conflicts.

Learning Objective 2: idendity areas for interventions for Korean American adolescents and their parents.

Purpose: Little is known about Korean American adolescents’ (KAA) and their parents’ perceptions of parental knowledge about adolescents’ school life, parental/filial self-efficacy to communicate, parent-child communication, and parent-child conflicts. Even less is known about the congruity of parents’ and adolescents’ perceptions. A lack of parental knowledge, inadequate parent-child communication, and increased parent-child conflicts resulting from immigration have been associated with adolescent’s mental health problems. This cross-sectional descriptive study examined the correlations between KAAs’ aged 11 to 14 years and their parents’ report of parental knowledge, parental/filial self-efficacy, parent-child communication, and parent-child conflicts.
Theoretical Framework: The Social Cognitive Theory and the Social Ecology Theory guided this study.
Method: Thirty-one Korean American (KA) parent-child pairs from two KA churches completed the self-administered questionnaires: Knowledge of Adolescent’s School Life, Parental/Filial self-efficacy, Parent-Child Communication Scale for KAs, and Conflict Behavior Questionnaire (CBQ). Data were analyzed using Pearson correlations, followed by cross-classification tables, and chi-square and Kendal’s tau-b.
Results: Positive correlations between fathers’ and KAAs’ perceptions of parental knowledge, self-efficacy, parent-child communication, and parent-child conflicts were observed (P ≤ .05). Father and KAAs congruently reported that fathers have limited parental knowledge, low self-efficacy, limited communication with a child, and high parent-child conflicts. Positive correlations between mothers’ and KAAs’ perceptions of parental knowledge, self-efficacy, and parent-child conflicts were observed (P ≤ .05). Although mothers and KAAs agreed that the quality of their mother-child relationship was better than father-child relationship, mothers and KAAs showed incongruent perceptions of communication content and process.
Conclusions: Fathers’ limited knowledge and communication with a child, low self-efficacy, and high parent-child conflicts reflect traditional parenting roles in Korean culture: breadwinning fathers and nurturing mothers. Considering the fact that inadequate parent-child relationships may have adverse effects on KAAs’ mental health, it is necessary to develop interventions enhancing parent-child communication for KA families. The interventions need to be designed to promote fathers involvement in parenting.