Quantitative Results from Evaluation of Community Student Service-Learning in the Univeristy of North Florida Home-Base Model

Monday, 22 July 2013: 1:48 PM

Barbara J. Kruger, PhD, MPH, RN1
Kenneth T. Wilburn, PhD2
Barbara J. Olinzock, EdD, RN1
Connie S. Roush, PhD, RN1
(1)School of Nursing, University of North Florida, Jacksonville, FL
(2)Health-Tech Consultants, Inc., Neptune Beach, FL

Purpose: This study evaluates student learning outcomes of the UNF Home-base Model, a cross-term curriculum that places students in the same community for their entire nursing program. Although community curricula are abundant, their evaluation is largely absent, and this limits evidence for academic practice.

Methods: Following IRB approval a rolling recruitment began in 2008 and ended in 2010 to enroll 9 cohorts of students entering the baccalaureate nursing program. Study investigators met with students to explain the mixed-methods, repeated measures protocol. Students enrolled in the 5 semester traditional pre-licensure program were surveyed at entry, mid-point, and exit from the program while 3 semester post-baccalaureate students were surveyed at entry and exit using the Community Nursing Student Assessment Scale (CNSAS, α = 0.986).

Results: Response rate was 70% (n=170). Median student age was 22 years. Students were mostly female (84.7%, n=144)), Caucasian/White (78.8%, n=134), reporting English as their primary language (98%, n=167). Comparison of student learning outcomes measured by the CNSAS showed that student mean scores on all 39 items significantly improved between entry and exit from the program. Many students (91%, n=154) were “extremely, very, or somewhat likely” to consider future community/public health nursing practice and 67.6% (n=115) reported that the amount of time (110-150 hours) they spent in the community across the curriculum was “about right” while 28% (n=48) said it was “too little” time. Limitations include convenience sampling and no control group.

Conclusion: Results of this evaluation indicate positive student outcomes related to health promotion, community engagement, partnering, acknowledging ecological health determinants, and self-efficacy. Student’s value community nursing and their positive experience may influence eventual career choice. Future evaluation should consider comparison to a control group from a comparable nursing program operating a traditional one-semester community clinical curriculum.