Identifying Barriers for Nephrology Nurses in Discussing Advance Care Planning (ACP) With CKD Patients

Thursday, 25 July 2019: 3:50 PM

Chiu-Chu Lin, PhD
School of Nursing, Kaohsiung Medical University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan
Jui-O Chen, RN
Nursing, Tajen University, Pingtung, Taiwan

Background: The prevalence and incidence of end stage renal disease (ESRD) in Taiwan is the highest in the world. Patients with ESRD may need to depend on hemodialysis of life-sustaining treatment for survival. If health professionals (HPs) can initiate advance care planning (ACP) with patients and assist them in signing advance directives (AD), patients may avoid facing medical futility. However, the overall rate of AD completion in Taiwan is lower than western countries. Therefore, the barriers in discussing ACP with patients (CKD) are in need to be explored.

Purpose: The study aimed to elaborate nurses’ experiences and identify their barriers in ACP for patients with CKD.

Methods: A purposive sampling was used to recruit nurses who had worked at least one year in nephrology department from one medical center and four regional hospitals. A qualitative content analysis was applied to examine the interview data from six focus groups with a total of 33 participants.

Results: Seven major themes were revealed as follows:

Theme 1: ACP is often considered to be related to death, which is a taboo issue in Taiwanese society; Theme 2: It is difficult to find a good timing to discuss ACP with patients; Theme 3: A lack of knowledge of ACP and communication skills; Theme 4: Patients or their family members refuse discussing ACP due to certain misunderstanding; Theme 5: Nurses consider themselves lacking the characteristics to discuss ACP with patients; Theme 6: Conflicts regarding ACP belief occurred between doctors and nurses; Theme 7: Initiating ACP is not only nurses’ responsibility.

Conclusion: The findings will help HPs better understand the nurses’ barriers in discussing ACP with CKD patients. Its implications are as follows. First, HPs should enhance their knowledge and skills of ACP in order to facilitate the shared decision-making process. Second, HPs should encourage patients and their family to participate in decision making to avoid medical futility. Third, health providers are recommended to initiate ACP and further discuss in detail to improve end-of-life care. If HPs can be aware of these barriers and work together with one another, ACP as the norm for everyone can become possible in the near future.

See more of: B 15
See more of: Research Sessions: Oral Paper & Posters