Paper
Thursday, July 12, 2007
Grandmothers Rearing Grandchildren: An Evidence-Based Theory of the Problem
Margaret Shandor Miles, PhD, RN, FAAN, School of Nursing, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA and Lenora Campbell, DNS, RN, Department of Nursing, Winston Salem State University of N.C, Winston Salem, NC, USA.
Learning Objective #1: The learner will be able to identify factors affecting stress in custodial grandmothers |
Learning Objective #2: The learning will be able to list approaches to designing interventions for custodial grandmothers |
Children being raised by
grandparents are one of the fastest growing groups of children in the United
States and the world. Most of the
caregivers providing this “kinship care” are grandmothers. Often, the circumstances
are borne out of complex life experiences such as parental illness especially
HIV, child abuse and neglect, and maternal incarceration often related to drug
and alcohol abuse. While there is a growing literature about custodial
grandmothers, most studies are descriptive and atheoretical. There is a need
for a theory depicting the issues and needs of custodial grandparents from an
ecological holistic, developmental perspective. Based on field notes, observations, focus group data, and
questionnaires from our work with a community-based Grandparenting Program and
a related self-care and parenting intervention, we developed a model based on
Elder's Life Course perspective. In
this model, we consider the socio-cultural context and the life trajectory of
the grandmother, her adult child, and the grandchild(ren) as these lives
intersect to influence the challenges faced by grandmothers. This includes the ongoing social and health
problems of the adult child and the behavioral, health, and development
problems of the grandchild(ren) who have been affected by the parents'
lifestyle and problems. Thus three
major challenges face grandmothers: (a) dealing with her relationship with and
feelings about her adult child; (b) managing the challenges of parenting the
grandchild; and (c) meeting her own personal needs while caring for
others. This model depicting the
“theory of the problem” provides a guide for interventions which must be aimed
at all three challenges in order to reduce the stress of custodial
grandparents, increase their effectiveness in parenting, and prevent adverse
physical and emotional outcomes. The model has potential for intervening with
custodial grandmothers in other parts of the world such as Africa.