Practice-Based Knowledge Japanese Midwives Use in Assessing the Progress of Labor and Their Underlying Experiences

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Keiko Masaoka, PhD
School of Health Sciences, Sapporo Medical University, Sapporo, Japan
Tomoko Maruyama, PhD
Department of Nursing and Nutrition, Thenshi College, Sapporo, Japan
Yoshiko Hayashi, MA
Department of Nursing, The Japanese Red Cross Hokkaido College of Nursing, Kitami, Japan
Manami Yoshida, MA
School of Health Sciences, Sapporo Medical University, Japan, Japan

Learning Objective 1: The learner will be able to recognize the importance of seising lessons from experience, encouraged by the proven practices of Japanese midwives.

Learning Objective 2: The learner will be able to acquire new perspectives on midwifery experience, discovering a set of experience which is required to develop one’s career.

In order to identify practice-based knowledge acquired by midwives, ten midwives with up to ten years in midwifery (“younger group” 4.75 years in midwifery on average) and 21 midwives with a longer experience (“older group” 19.75 years) were asked to talk about memorable experiences between January 2008 and November 2009.  Narratives were analyzed using Kelly’s method.  This research had a prior approval of the Ethical Committee of Sapporo Medical University.

Nine categories of knowledge identified from the younger group include:- determining whether to wait in the prolonged delivery or not; visually estimating the bleeding and urination volume; assessing the need for episiotomy/avoiding perineum laceration; coping with sudden changes in condition of mother/baby; realizing grave responsibilities because “every childbirth is unique and anything can happen”.  Among the underlying experiences were building a relationship gradually; providing care to high risk cases; feedback, self-reflection and realizing limits of own ability/midwifery.

11 categories extracted from the older group include:- engaging with the woman discreetly, allowing her body to take its natural course; knowing one’s remit; assessing the fetal condition and the women’s states through visual inspection/ palpation; “challenges where one’s accountability is at stake sharpen own ability to judge; and “the full moon influences childbirth”.  The underlying experiences include providing continuous care throughout pregnancy; staying with the woman during labor, allowing her to give birth her way where possible; arranging transfer to hospital; knowing one’s limit; training in palpation and inspection; learning from failures and others.

Those up to ten years in midwifery are expected to have acquired knowledge on how to deal with sudden changes in condition and provide case-specific care while realizing own responsibilities.  Those with a longer experience are expected to have built the ability to detect problems, assess the woman’s inner feelings and do the best within own remit.